Technical Analysis: pros and cons of MACD | Forex4you (2024)

Reading time: 3 minutes

Technical Analysis: pros and cons of MACD | Forex4you (3)

Excerpt: Do you use the momentum indicator, MACD for your technical analysis? Here are the basics that you should know, along with the pros and cons of this indicator.

The moving average convergence divergence (MACD) is a momentum indicator that follows the trend. This indicator is made available for traders trading with Forex4you. This indicator is made up of a MACD line and a signal line. The MACD line is derived by the subtraction of a certain EMA period from another. The image below shows a 13,21,8 MACD.

The first is the fast 13 period EMA and then the slow 21 period EMA. The MACD line (shown as the grey histogram) is automatically plotted. It can be calculated by subtracting the slow EMA from the fast EMA. The third MA - 8 period SMA (simple moving average) is plotted across the grey histogram. It is shown by the red dotted line and is usually called the signal line. The basis of the combination is to give a buy and sell signal on any instrument it is plotted and on any time frame. The MACD automatically adjusts to a new time frame. The settings on the MT4 can be changed. The default setting on MT4 is 12,26,9.

What information does the MACD give?

Indicators are mathematical computations and each often tells a different story. The MACD shows a positive value once the fast EMA is above the slow EMA and a negative value, if the slow EMA is above the fast EMA. The MACD has a baseline of zero on Mt4. The farther the MACD is above or below the zero line, the more distant the two EMAs are from each other. This indicates a growing price trend. When the MACD draws close to zero, it shows a weakness in the prevailing trend. Primarily, if the MACD stays above zero, the trend is bullish while below zero indicates a bearish trend. The longer the MACD stays above or below the zero line, the more prevalent the trend.

Technical Analysis: pros and cons of MACD | Forex4you (5)

The trend above is bullish on the 15 mins time frame. The MACD stayed above with dips toward the zero line, which showed minor weaknesses. The bullish trend prevailed as MACD quickly returned above the zero line to expand further. The bearish trend will start if the price drops far below the zero line and extends its stay there.

1. MACD crossovers

This is one of the most popular ways of MACD application. In an uptrend (when the signal line and MACD are above the zero line), if the signal line crosses below the MACD histogram, it means the prevailing trend will be weak. However, after the weakness, the signal line crosses above the MACD, it indicates a bullish trend continuation. In a downtrend (when the MACD and the signal line are below the zero line), if the signal line crosses the MACD upwards, it indicates bearish trend weakness. If after the weakness, the signal line crosses the MACD downwards, it indicates bearish trend continuation.

Technical Analysis: pros and cons of MACD | Forex4you (6)

The blue arrows on the price indicate buy signals. Buying into the bullish trend. The same principle applies to the downtrend

2. Price-MACD divergence

When the MACD makes a high and low that diverge from the corresponding highs and lows on the price, this scenario is called a divergence.

Technical Analysis: pros and cons of MACD | Forex4you (7)

A bearish divergence forms a higher high on the price and a lower high on the MACD. Bearish divergence gives a sell signal. A bullish divergence occurs when the price makes a lower low while the MACD makes a higher low. This indicates a buy signal.

Pros and Cons of using MACD

Pros

  • MACD can be used as a trend indicator and a momentum indicator.

  • MACD provides clear buy and sell signals using the MACD crossover and the divergence explained above

  • MACD can be used in combination with other technical methods for more clarity.

Cons

  • It can provide false reversals. Sometimes reversal signals shown by the MACD divergence does not mean a significant reversal would happen. It could mean that a temporary pause or sideways move is underway before the trend continues. Therefore, MACD cannot forecast all reversals.

  • MACD does not often give an accurate analysis of a trend many times. Trend following signals could also fail or provide insignificant move before a trend reversal.

In other news…

Trading for Beginners: How to Avoid Common Mistakes

Sustainable side hustles: eco-friendly ways to boost your income

Is work life balance important in forex?

A Comprehensive Guide to CFD Trading for Beginners: Exploring Opportunities with Forex4you

Forex Day Trading Strategies

How to Manage Risk in Forex Trading

3 Tips to Understanding The Psychology Of Trading

Technical Analysis: pros and cons of MACD | Forex4you (2024)

FAQs

What are the advantages and disadvantages of MACD? ›

Pros and cons of using MACD

Another big advantage is that you can adjust the MACD to different chart time frames, making it a versatile tool for short-term or long-term trades. The biggest disadvantage of the MACD? It can sometimes lag because it's based on moving averages (past data).

What is the major flaw of MACD? ›

MACD is a popular technical indicator used by traders across many different markets, however its usefulness has been questioned. One of the main problems with divergence is that it can often signal a possible reversal but then no actual reversal actually happens—it can produce a false positive.

Do professional traders use MACD? ›

MACD is a trend-following momentum indicator that shows the relationship between two moving averages of a security's price. Traders use the MACD to identify entry and exit points for trades.

What is the success rate of MACD strategy? ›

MACD with PRC has a 90% success rate. A stock's moving averages should at least approach one another, if not cross, before you act on that stock. MACDs rely on three exponential moving averages instead of one or two. Look for patterns where the three moving averages come together closely.

Is MACD good for day trading? ›

Though it is not useful for intraday trading, the MACD can be applied to daily, weekly, or monthly price charts. The basic MACD trading strategy uses a two-moving-averages system—one 12-period and one 26-period—along with a nine-day exponential moving average (EMA) that serves to produce clear trading signals.

How to use MACD effectively? ›

The strategy is to buy – or close a short position – when the MACD crosses above the zero line, and sell – or close a long position – when the MACD crosses below the zero line.

Is there a better indicator than MACD? ›

The Schaff Trend Cycle (STC) is a technical analysis indicator used in trading and investing to identify trends and generate trading signals. The STC indicator helps to identify trends in a smoother and more responsive manner compared to traditional MAs and even under certain parameters, the MACD.

Which is more accurate RSI or MACD? ›

The MACD is known for its accuracy in identifying trends and momentum in the market, while the RSI is better at detecting overbought or oversold conditions. Despite their usefulness, both indicators can produce false signals if used in isolation or with the default setting.

When not to use MACD? ›

Strong trend: When the market is in a strong trend, the MACD may lag behind the price action and generate signals too late. Traders may want to use other indicators, such as the Relative Strength Index (RSI) or the Stochastic Oscillator, to complement the MACD in these situations.

What time frame is best for MACD? ›

The MACD line is calculated by subtracting the 26-period exponential moving average (EMA) from the 12-period EMA. The signal line is a nine-period EMA of the MACD line. MACD is best used with daily periods, where the traditional settings of 26/12/9 days is the default.

Can I use MACD for scalping? ›

The best forex scalping indicator depends on your trading style, but MACD is a common choice due to its ability to identify the strength, direction, momentum, and duration of a trend.

What is the disadvantage of MACD? ›

Cons of using the MACD

If a trader has a longer-term outlook that this, the MACD may not be suitable. Another potential downside is that the MACD is a trend following indicator. This means that the indicator gives its signals as the trend occurs, not before it starts.

Which indicator has the highest accuracy? ›

The Moving Average Convergence Divergence (MACD) indicator is often considered one of the most accurate technical indicators. That is because it uses a combination of moving averages to spot potential buy and sell signals.

How accurate is MACD strategy? ›

Notice that the initial cross occurred well below the zero line. If we go back a few weeks, we will see the same action signaling a strong sell-off. In both cases, the cross occurred well above or below the zero line (see chart below). MACD is one of the most versatile and accurate indicators for retail traders.

What is the importance of MACD? ›

It excels in identifying trends, assessing momentum, and providing signals for trend reversals and overbought/oversold conditions. MACD's ability to help traders time their buy and sell decisions is invaluable, enabling them to optimise their strategies for maximising profits and minimising losses.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Horacio Brakus JD

Last Updated:

Views: 5497

Rating: 4 / 5 (71 voted)

Reviews: 86% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Horacio Brakus JD

Birthday: 1999-08-21

Address: Apt. 524 43384 Minnie Prairie, South Edda, MA 62804

Phone: +5931039998219

Job: Sales Strategist

Hobby: Sculling, Kitesurfing, Orienteering, Painting, Computer programming, Creative writing, Scuba diving

Introduction: My name is Horacio Brakus JD, I am a lively, splendid, jolly, vivacious, vast, cheerful, agreeable person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.