Juarez v. Securus Techs. (2024)

1

RICKY JOE JUAREZ; NIEVES ORTEGA; TRAMAINE JERNIGAN; MICHAEL J. PADILLA; DAVID S. PETERSON; CHRISTOPHER DEE; ORLANDO SINTAS; FRANCISCO MARTINEZ; JAMAL YOUNG; IVAN MILLES; STEVEN GILKEY; GARY ROYBAL; JUAN P. ALICEA; JOSEPH CHAVEZ; RONALD R. YAZZIE; ALISHA FLORENCE; MERLE CLAY EDAAKIE, JR.; SHAWN PAUL LOYD; THOMAS BAHNEY; JASON A. COHOE; GABRIEL GASPER; VALERIE DEE; ANGELA GASPER; RITA JOLLY; EDDY GARCIA; ALLAN HURLEY; LYDIA ROYBAL; JOSEPH M. BROWN; LARRY M. BEACH; MICHAEL CONTRERAS; VICENTE BACA; RAYMOND E. LUCERO; AGUAPITO ARUJO; CORRINA ARUJO; DANIEL ROYBAL; MIGUEL G. SILVA; JORGE LUIS SOTELO; GERALD MONTANO; JENNIFER JUAREZ; WALTER SCOTT FINNELL; WILLIAM MATER; ADAM T. MCVEAY; VALDA J. TUETKEN; NATHAN TAYLER; RAYMOND M. WARD; GARY SHEPHERD; DAVID BENAVIDEZ; TYRONE BOOTH; RUBEN LUCERO; JAMES A. MIERITZ; GERONIMO VIGIL; MICHAEL CLAYTON; NIC AKER; JOSEPH A. GARNER; ADRIAN JEROME GRIMES; JOE CARABAJAL, JR.; TYRONE VAUGHN; CASKA ROBERTSON -LITTLE; ALBERTO G. ROBLES; ALVIN MARTIN, JR.; LARRY PONE; JEREMY HICKS; GAR MEDINA; JOSH ADAMS; LOUIS MONTOYA, JR.; ANDREA HERNANDEZ; VICTOR MONTOYA; JAIME ORTEGA; JEFF GALLEGOS; ALVIN F. MARTIN, SR.; ALBERT LOUIS MONTOYA; STEPHEN E. VALENZUELA; DIANA MAESTAS; LAVERN MAESTAS; JUSTIN EUGENE HATCH; JEFF HOOGERHUIS; JACOB M. GONZALES; MARQUISE ELIZONDO; JULIAN TAFOYA; GERARD B. PARVILUS; CHRISTOPHER FREED; JOSE AVILA; STEPHEN ALVAREZ; DANIEL GLOVER; STEWART P. RODRIGUEZ; RORY SANTISTEVAN, SR.; HECTOR SERNA; FREDDIE SERRANO; MARTY BEGAY; UBALDO CARAVEO; VELLENE EVANS; RAMON GONZALEZ; DIANA CROWSON; ERMINIO ACOSTA; PILAR SALAZAR; CLOYCEVANN SALAZAR; SHILO THOMAS SAVOIE; RICKY GONZALES; ISAAC MONTOYA; PRISCILLA MONTOYA; DANIEL GALLEGOS; JOSHUA JAMES MONTOYA; MICHAEL ARTHUR BROWN; NICHOLAS JAMES JONES; JOHN A. BRINSFIELD; ISAAC LEONARD ROMERO; JESUCITA SALAZAR; ALBERT P. LOPEZ; JOHNNY SALAZAR; JOSE A. GARCIA; ANTHONY P. MERRITT; MOSES INGRAM; JESUS FLORES ORDONEZ; GENE MARTINEZ; ANTHONY TAFOYA; ISAAC MONTANO; ROBERT TENORIO; JOSE A. RIVERA; KENNETH E. TRIGGS; JIMMY BACA; EDWARD ADAMS; JESSE L. GARCIA; CHRISTOPHER MARQUEZ; JOSE GALLEGOS; BETTY HERNANDEZ; JANAE MARQUEZ; ROYLENE WHATLEY; ANTJUAN MCGHEE; JAIME LOPEZ; ANDY M. PEREZ; ANIBAL ORTIZ; MARQUE CHEEKS; JOANN WALLACE; CHRISTOPHER D. PAYTON; LEONEL LOPEZ; BLANCA NEVAREZ; RICHARD H. SIGALA; DAVID COELHO; JOSHUA URIOSTE; CARL M. ARAGON; ROBERT F. COLBORN; DANIEL JACOB MARTINEZ; ELMORE KEMP; MICHAEL L. BORNHOLDT; TONY MORALES JR.; JESSE D. BURDEX, JR.; CARL BELL; JAMES SHON WILSON; LARRY LUCERO; THOMAS E. MONTOYA; ALBERT TEGEDA III; BRANDON FLEMMING; ANTHONY L. JIMENEZ; JOHN LABOMBARD, JR.; MELICENDRO MARTINEZ; JEREMY D. SMITH; GEORGE E. MONTOYA, JR.; ISAAC RODRIGUEZ; JUSTIN EASLEY; DANIEL SALAS; ERIKA PADILLA; NICK JASPER; LISA LASTER; AARON REESE; ERIC R. FIERRO; SEAN M. STOLZ; ELRICO S. CUMMINGS; AUGUSTIN F. GRANADO; FRANK GARCIA; SEAN BROUGHTON; CHRISTOPHER HOUSTON; ALLEN BERGERON; JESSE LA-CASSE; ROBERT M. BERTOLA; BRANDON SELF; CARTRELL R. SMITH; EUGENE J. URIOSTE; MICHAEL SHAFFAR; JEREMAIS NIETO; LEROY DOODY, JR.; MARIO RUDOLFO; PAUL VALDEZ; GUJUAN FUSILIER; ROBERT SAIZ; LEONA F. STROTMAN; JOHN MEISTER; KEVIN COATS; SANTIAGO J. MATA; SHAUN A. BIRD; SEYMOUR BACA; BRADLEY PAUL FECHT; TIMMITHEY STOVER; CHARLES BATES; CHRISTOPHER BROCKERMAN; FABIAN MARTINEZ; JUSTIN CARTER; DARRELL S. WILLIAMS; CORNELIO M. HOLGUIN; ELIODORO MAGANA; HECTOR VEGA; JEREMY WOOD; JOE CASTILLO; AMOS CORPUS; PABLO JOSHUA GONZALEZ; GILBERTO HERNANDEZ; ARTURO MEDINA; PAUL SALAS; ARES BROWN; SALVADOR JARAMILLO; GILBERT SERRANO; RYAN LEWIS; JOSHUA IVERY; JAMES MARTIN; MARIO AGUILERA; JUAN URIBE; ROBERTO GONZALES; ISRAEL PRIMERA; DAVID MARRAH; OSHAY TONEY; FREDDY BACA; DERRICK CANDELARIA; CAMEO TYRELL BONNER; JAIME CARRERA; CHRISTOPHER MONTOYA; CESAR ACEVES; MANUEL CONTRERAS; JESUS MARTINEZ; THOMAS MILLINGTON; FRANK ALVEY; JIMMY SAIZ; GABRIEL MONTOYA; MICHAEL TRUJILLO; RICKY VIGIL; GERALD WILSON; JOSHUA NESTLE; ARMANDO VENEGAS; RICARDO VALDEZ; ERIC RODRIGUEZ; BRIAN SPINDEN; ERNESTO PINEDA; DESI CORDOVA; BEAU MUSACCO; EARL ROMO; FRANCISCO LUJAN; GEORGE VELA; STEVE SWAYNE; ROBERT URIOSTE; JOHNNY RAY VALLEJIO; JUAN RIOS; JOHN R. CASTRO; JAMES ORTEGA; PAUL MARTIN; ED GILCHRIST, JR.; CHRIS SAIS; JESUS MORALES; EDWARD BACA; DONALD R. FAIN; IRVIN PEREZ; JESSE I. CHAVEZ; JUAN MURO; SONNY MELENDREZ; NICHOLAS LOPEZ; CLARENCE RAY PERGESON; PETE ROBERT ROMERO; SHAWN C. PARIS; DANIEL KENOLIO; DAVIS EDDIE WILSON; JEREMY JARAMILLO; MELVIN WRIGHT; RUBEN PERALTA; JUAN I. GUTIERREZ; MARK COCHRAN; SHANNON RAY CRADDOCK; DAVID GUTIERREZ, II; TRINITY JENNIE ROMERO; ANDRES MAJACA; ROBERT ANAYA; STEVAN CHAVEZ; JOHN HOOVER; JAMES JOSEPH LINCK; PETE ROBERT ROMERO; MOSES MENCHACA; NATHAN LENTE GARCIA; PATRICIO LUCERO; DOMINIC CONYERS; DEATHONEY P. BOX; CARL BERRY; JERRY CHAVEZ; SALVADOR ARNOLDO NAVARETTE; RYAN E. KLEIN; ZACHARY KRIESEL; BRYCE FRANKLIN; SANDRA HERNANDEZ; RAMONA AQUINO; PIO AQUINO; LAWRENCE MARQUEZ; CHRISTOPHER COOPER; MICHELLE SALAZAR; JAMES A. SENA, II; ROBERT GLENN EARLEY; ANDREW LUCERO; MARIO SEDILLO; FERNANDO MONTOYA; MICHAEL GARCIA; SHAWN L. JACOBS; RICARDO D. MARTINEZ; RAHMON LEE UECKLER; JARRELL FRAZIER; NICHOLAS CASTELLANES; ANTHONY MILLIGAN; ARIF ABDULRAFT; ENRIQUE CARMONA; DANA PERGESON; ARTHUR ANAYA; MARK STAAKE; TIJERAREO CASTILLO; RUBEN LOVATO; ANTHONY QUINTANA; DANIEL S. REICHMAN; PETE MACIAS; ADRIAN G. SEDILLO; JORDAN WAYNE HURD; KENTON WARNOCK; ORLANDO FLORES; CHEE LIVINGSTON; MARVIN D. MONTOYA; ROBERT SAMMY BACA; ALREE B. SWEAT, III; JESUS DURAN; DELVIN PAZ JR.; JUAN M. GARCIA; NONA L. MCCRAIG; ANDREW SANTILLANES; TYRONE SMITH; ROBERT V. VASQUEZ; RODOLFO MARTINEZ; SEAN FEURTADO; FARREL WHEELER; RAMON HORTON; SPENSER MERCER PHILLIPS; JOHN MALINS; MICHAEL S. PITTMAN; DARNYLE PIOCHE; KEVIN SUTPHIN; CARLOS M. HERRERA; ROBERT V. GARCIA; ISMAEL TORRES; JUSTINE GILES; TERRILL SMOLAR; TEVON STEVENS; URIAH F. BACA; MARK BRADFORD; JOVANNAH C. SANDOVAL; RAHMON ROBEY; MARCELLA GORE; ISRAEL HERRERA; LARRY JOHNSON; EDWARD JUDE BACA; JARRELL FRAZIER; DALLAS HNULICK; PAUL JOHNSON; DANIEL JOSE AGUILAR; JACOB NICHOLAS; JACKIE HINES; ISABEL PERALTA; HECTOR GARCIA; BERNARDINO T. BACA; TIMOTHY V. MORA; NATHAN MONTOYA; JAVIER PEREZ; JOEY ROSAS; DENNYS MATEO; BARNARDO VALDEZ; MANUEL C. SANCHEZ; LORENZO SALAS; DOMINIC PACK; JESSE LUNA; EDWARD SALAS; JULIUS TONEY; ALEXIS R. ANAYA; JUAQUIN PADILLA; ELOY AGUILAR; JAMES D. PACE; VINCENT VENEGAS; MICHAEL ORTEGA; DANIEL SANDOVAL; MICHAEL GARCIA; RAYMOND LOLLIS; ANH HUYNH; DOMINICK SMITH; ROBERT M. LUCERO; JOSHUA PUENTE; FABIAN ROMERO; STANFORD E. SANDOVAL; ERIC VALDEZ; TERRY JOHNSON; ROGELIO ESPARZA; DYLAN K. RIVERA; DAWN JOHNSON SWEENEY; LOUIS GUERRA; NATHANIEL A. KURTOK; DOMINIC BAILEY; MATTHEW S. TRUJILLO; GABRIEL GONZALEZ; JUSTIN J. MILLER; VINCENT M. ALVAREZ; EDUARDO RAMIREZ; RYAN N. DIMAS; LAWRENCE GALLEGOS; NATHAN LENTE GARCIA; RICHARD K. OTERO; JOSE A. CORRAL; GILBERT M. CORIZ; WALTER S. BEGAY; JUAN SALCIDO; JESSE E. MITCHELL; ROCKY CHAVEZ; ALFONSO RODRIGUEZ; JOHN GROSSETETE; DAVID TOMSIK; ALEJANDO SANDOVAL; DANIEL LOPEZ; JOHN H. ESTRADA; GABRIEL W. CORDOVA; FRANKIE C. TRUJILLO; ODEN GUTIERREZ; LARRY A. TURNER; JEREMY J. KLINE; WILLIAM MCGHEE; JASON REID; RICHARD BACA; ADAM MISQUEZ; RICHARD BORREGO; ROY A. HOLLIDAY; JOBE A. TOLER; GREGORY MARTINEZ; MANUEL GARDNER; DEMETRIO MUNOZ; LARRY GALLEGOS; JOSEPH L. PHILLIPS; LUIS TRUJILLO; TYLER STROTMAN; PETER P. BACA; FRANK OSBORN; VICTOR A. MONTANO, JR.; BRANDEN M. ADKINS; CHRISTOPHER J. RAINS; ROCKY JOE RAMER; CHRISTOPHER AYALA; JIMMY RAY O'KELLEY; ELMER ESTRADA; THOMAS J. MANNING; ANTHONY WALLACE; DONALD MCCOMAS; LARRY LOPEZ; ALBERT MONCADA; ALFREDO VARGAS; BRYON DAUGHTRY; TIMOTHY H. JOHNSON; GARY STEVENS; JUSTIN TIPTON; CECIL BOYETT; RENE LOBOS; MICHAEL FOX; ANDREA SUTPHIN; JACK RIVERA; ETHAN BILLIE; CHRISTOPHER GAMBLE; MANUEL GUTIERREZ; KEVIN PERKINS; MATTHEW MCCLELLAND; ANTONIO SENA; JEFFERSON PAU; JOE JACOB GONZALES; MARCOS ARAGON; ADAM ROWLEY; MILO BENALLY; NATHAN ROBERTS; DALE DIXON; DANIEL MARTINEZ; MANUEL SILVA; ANTHONY AGUILAR; JESUS NARANJO; CHARLES RICHARDS; JACOB JARAMILLO; DOMEKIO BLACKWELL; JACOB PRIEB; JOSEPH A. MAESTAS; ANGELO RODRIGUEZ; GUSTAVO ALBARENGA; ELI MUNGUIA; JAMES PARMENTIER; AARON ORTEGA; SAMMUEL AQUIAR; MICHAEL A. VALENCIA; JOE RUBEN MONTEZ; DEREK DUARTE; TIMOTHY JARAMILLO; LEO GALINDO; EDUARDO CHAVEZ; DAVIS MCLESKEY; DAMION DAVIS; OCTAVIO PRIETA; GENOVEVO GALLEGOS; LARRY HERNANDEZ; KYLE MENDENHALL; ANTHONY RIVAS; VICTOR ANDREW APODACA, SR.; EARL TIDD; CHRISTOPHER LOVATO; GABRIEL ARMENDARIZ; NICOLES L. DAVIS; DAVID GRIEGO; JUSTIN MUNIZ; GABRIEL J. MONTOYA; COLLEY LAMAR INGRAM; PETER DEAN MENDOZA; LEONARD DAVIS; RONALD SANCHEZ; STEVE M. CASAUS; EDMUNDO RIOS; EUGENE FERRI; CHRISTOPHER J. GARCIA; JUAN M. FLORES; KEVIN VIOLA; TRACY JOHNSON; EDGAR R. THOMAS; CLAYTON W. WHITEHEAD; ALEJANDRO STEELE; VAN LYDELL STARLING; VICTOR JARAMILLO; BRIAN PULLIAM; CHRISTOPHER FERNANDEZ; DUSTIN J. BINGHAM; KEITH BAILEY; FABIAN GALLEGOS; MICHAEL LOZANO; JOSHUA HERNANDEZ; EUSEBIO JASPER; OSCAR MUNOZ; JULIA GONZALES; NATHANIAL DURAN; CARLOS PANDO; FREDERICK J. WILLIAMS; JESSE LYN BRADLEY; VICTOR PAIZ; EDWARD SOTO MILLER; DONNY MALDONADO; RICHARD REES; SHAUN LOPEZ; ANTHONY ABEYTA; DARIUS GONZALES; JOSE CHAVARRIA; and VINCENT VASQUEZ, Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. SECURUS TECHNOLOGIES, LLC; and NEW MEXICO CORRECTIONS DEPARTMENT, Defendants-Appellees, and JERRY ROARK; JAMES BREWSTER; GREG MARCANTEL; and NEW MEXICO GENERAL SERVICES DEPARTMENT, in substitution for TRAVIS DUTTON-LEYBA Defendants.

No. A-1-CA-40165

Court of Appeals of New Mexico

January 29, 2024

David S. Peterson, et al.

Clayton, NM Pro...