Is it worth making a claim on car insurance? (2024)

What are the pros and cons of making a car insurance claim? 

There are many benefits and downsides to making a car insurance claim.Yourindividual circ*mstances will ultimately determine what the best action to take is, as well as your insurance policy.Some pros to consider are:

More affordable if substantial damage has been caused 

If the damage costs more to repair than the value of your premium, it may be worth making a claim. This is simply because it will save you money on the repairs, especially if the damage is substantial anyway.

Potentialpay-outtowards a new car if yours has been written off 

Your car insurance policy maystate that the insurer will contribute towards the cost of a new car– ifyours is written off.Under these circ*mstances, it’s definitely a good idea toclaim and saveyourselfsome money.Even if your insurance goes up, you’ll probably still be betteroffinancially.

Access to a courtesy car 

Again, your insurer might provide you with access to a courtesy car while yours is getting fixed or whileyou shop around for a new one. You’d need to claim in order tobenefit fromthis.

Reassurance that it is being dealt with properly 

It can be stressful dealing with car repairs on your own, especially if you’ve been in a bad accident or its your first timehaving tomake repairs. The insurerwill be able to offer you advice and reassure you that the situation is being dealt with.

Cons of making a car insurance claim: 

Make sure you also consider the cons ofmaking a car insurance claim, so that you make a well-informed decision. Some cons you should know aboutinclude:

Potentiallylosingyour no-claims bonus 

If you have a no-claims bonus, you risk losing it by making a claim. Work out whether it would be more cost-effective to pay for the damage yourself, or to make the claim andlose that no claims bonus.This also depends on whether the incident was a ‘no-fault’ accidentor not, combined with your company policy.If you’ve protected yourno claims bonus, the number of years that contribute to it shouldn’t be affected by you making a claim.

Havingyour excess deducted from anypay-outyou receive 

If you’re entitled to apayoutfrom your insurer, it’s likely that any excess you’ve agreed to pay will be deducted from this amount.In some cases,you could end up beingpaidrelatively littlefrom your insurer and your insurance getting considerably more expensive as a result of your claim.If this is the likely outcome, then you may want to consider not claiming.

Your insurance goingup 

Insurers calculate the cost of your insurance based on various statistics. These include risk factors, likehow many claims you’ve made previously and how many accidents you’ve been in – whether you’ve claimed or not.It’s also worth noting thatyou shouldtell your insurer about the accidentanyway. Otherwise,yourpolicy could become void.

Being addedto the motor insurance database 

When you claim on the insurance, even if it wasn’t your fault, the incident is reported on the motor insurance database. This gives insurers an indication of how risky you are. So, your insurance could go up even if you weren’t at fault,if your driving history suggests that you’re a high-risk driver. 

How else can I reduce my car insurance rates? 

In some cases, going through the car insurance claims process with your insurer may be unavoidable. However,there are other things you can do to help bring your insurance down: 

Opt for multi-car insurance 

Multi-car discounts can help to bring your premium down.This is basically where you insure multiple cars on the same policy. For example,yours and your partner’s, children’s or parents’ cars.

Take a Pass Plus course 

APassPluscourse isa short, six-hourcoursethat helps inexperiencedandunconfidentdriversimprove their driving skills.There isn’t a test, but youhave toreach the required standard by the endof each modulein order to pass. Youhave topay for it, but it can knock a significant amountof money off your insurance.

Go for black box insurance 

Black box insurance uses GPS technology to measure how you drive andcan be cheaper than traditional car insurance.Onceyourdriving has been assessed, the provider may reduce your insurance.However, they aren’t cost effective for unsafe drivers, so bearthis in mind.

[Pull quote]There are plenty ofother waysyou can reduce your car insurance rates, so it’s worthtaking thetime to do as many of these as you can. [Pull quote]

What is a fault claim? 

There are two types of car insurance claims:

  • fault claim
  • non-fault claim

A fault claim doesn’t necessarily mean that you’re to blame for the accident. There are threeinstances where your insurer will file your claim as a fault claim:

  1. something youdid caused the accident
  2. someone who was driving your car caused the accident
  3. there wasn’t enough evidence to point towards somebody else as the culprit

For example,your car could be parked outside your housein the dead ofnightandsomebody vandalised it. If they were never caught, your insurer might put the claim down as a fault claim.

With a fault claim, your insurance company will be paying out for most of the damagescaused by the accident.

Does a non-fault claim affect insurance? 

A non-fault claim is where the accident is provento be somebody else’s fault. Their insurance will pay out for most of the costs.

Yourinsurance is less likely to go up(or by a lower amount) with a non-fault claim.That being said,insurerscalculatehow risky you are as a driveron a variety of factors.Some insurerstake into accountthe number of claims you’ve made, whetherthey were fault or non-fault. It really depends on your insurer. So, if your insurance goes up by a lot after your claim, it may be worth shopping around for a new provider.

Compare cheap car insurance quotes

  • Search over 100 providers
  • Quick and easy comparison tool

Compare now

Disclaimer: All information and links are correct at the time of publishing.

Is it worth making a claim on car insurance? (2024)

FAQs

At what point is it worth claiming on insurance? ›

If the damage costs more to repair than the value of your premium, it may be worth making a claim. This is simply because it will save you money on the repairs, especially if the damage is substantial anyway.

What is the downside of filing an insurance claim? ›

It could increase your premiums

The higher your perceived risk, the more likely you are to pay more in premiums. Your claims history tends to play a direct role. If you've filed homeowners insurance claims in the past, your insurer may see it as a red flag that you'll continue to do so in the future.

Is insurance claims worth it? ›

Key takeaways. Filing a home insurance claim might make the most sense when the loss estimate is more than your deductible. Any claim, even a minor one, might lead to an increase in your home insurance premium. Having frequent or repeat claims could cause a property insurer to nonrenew your policy.

Do insurance companies like claims? ›

Insurance companies aren't interested in helping you get the money you deserve after an accident. They'll do whatever they can to prevent or limit your payout. Many will even deny your seemingly legitimate claim. It's important to consider why insurance companies commonly deny insurance claims.

When not to make an insurance claim? ›

When not to file a car insurance claim
  1. You're involved in a minor accident and don't care to repair the damage.
  2. The cost of repairs is less than your deductible.
  3. You're concerned about possible rate increases.
Sep 20, 2023

Will my insurance increase after a claim? ›

Will my car insurance go up after an accident? Unfortunately, the simple answer to this is yes. Whether the accident was your fault or not, making a claim will usually lead to an increase in your car insurance premium the next year and you could see an increase even if you don't make a claim.

What to know before making a claim? ›

Check the following things before you send off your claim:
  • you're within the time limits for making a claim.
  • you're covered for what you're claiming for.
  • how much the excess is. The excess is the amount of money that your insurer will take off the claim. ...
  • the small print. ...
  • whether it's a new for old policy.

What are three important tips on filing an auto insurance claim? ›

Important Tips
  • Read your policy. ...
  • If you don't understand your policy, ask your agent and/or company for clarification.
  • If you have an accident, call the police. ...
  • Get as much information as possible at the accident scene to furnish to your agent and/or insurance company.

What to do before making a claim? ›

Create an inventory: Track all damaged property and include receipts and descriptions of each item in your log. Gather estimates: Try to estimate how much each part of the damaged property may cost. Update your adjuster: Give this information to your insurance adjuster to keep them in the loop.

Will my insurance go up if I make a lot of claims? ›

The greater the number of claims filed, the greater the likelihood of a rate hike. File too many claims—especially in a very short amount of time—and the insurance company may not renew your policy. If the claim is based on the damage you caused, your rates will almost surely rise.

Should I get an estimate before filing a claim? ›

If your vehicle was the only one to sustain damage — meaning that no other parties were involved — it's a good idea to get an estimate before making a claim. If the cost of repairs is small enough to comfortably pay out-of-pocket, it makes more sense to cover the expense yourself.

Is it better to pay cash or go through insurance? ›

An inexpensive accident with just you or your car

You'll have to pay for the damage yourself, whether it's buffing out a dent or fixing a crack in your glass. It's possible that your insurance deductible is higher than the out of pocket cost, so you may save money by choosing to pay for it on your own.

What not to say when filing a claim? ›

5 Things You Should Not Say to Car Insurance Adjusters
  1. Do Not Admit Fault. ...
  2. Do Not Minimize Personal Injuries to Adjuster. ...
  3. Do Not Describe Your Injuries. ...
  4. Do Not Hypothesize What Happened During the Accident. ...
  5. Do Not Provide a Recorded Statement.

How to get the most money out of an insurance claim? ›

Let's dive into the thick of it!
  1. Never Accept the First Offer.
  2. Never Sign Anything Before Consulting.
  3. Hire a Professional to Review and Give You Advice.
  4. Look Out for These Four Specifically.
  5. Show Proof if You Want to Argue the Estimate.
  6. Ensure the Insurance Company is Aware of Matching Elements That Also Need to be Replaced.
Jun 6, 2023

Why would insurance reject a claim? ›

In a claim denial letter, an insurance company may explain that the claim was rejected due to a technicality. This could mean an error made on the claim paperwork, such as missing important information. It could also mean that you filed your claim too late and missed the insurance company's deadline.

Does your insurance go up after a claim that is not your fault? ›

Under California law, an insurer cannot increase your premiums when you aren't at fault.

At what point should you insure a collection? ›

It's advisable to insure your collection as soon as its total value becomes significant to you. Whether your collection comprises artwork, coins, or musical instruments, protecting it with insurance offers peace of mind against potential risks such as theft, damage, or loss.

Why should you never make a claim that is lower than your deductible? ›

First the math: An obvious rule is don't file a claim if you're sure the damage is less than your deductible. If it is, you won't recover a dime from your insurer but the claim goes on your record and may put you in a higher risk/rate category – even if you didn't collect any benefits.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Corie Satterfield

Last Updated:

Views: 6400

Rating: 4.1 / 5 (42 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Corie Satterfield

Birthday: 1992-08-19

Address: 850 Benjamin Bridge, Dickinsonchester, CO 68572-0542

Phone: +26813599986666

Job: Sales Manager

Hobby: Table tennis, Soapmaking, Flower arranging, amateur radio, Rock climbing, scrapbook, Horseback riding

Introduction: My name is Corie Satterfield, I am a fancy, perfect, spotless, quaint, fantastic, funny, lucky person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.