Forex Trading Challenges in India | Kotak Securities (2024)

Key Highlights

Forex trading is gaining popularity in India, offering opportunities for financial gains through currency exchange. However, Indian traders face several challenges in this market.Legal restrictions imposed by RBI and SEBI limit trading options and currency pairs.Higher fees and spreads in the Indian forex industry compared to global standards can impact traders' profitability.Indian citizens can trade Forex through foreign brokers, but they have limited access to trading tools and currency pairs.Choosing authorized brokers registered with SEBI and adhering to RBI guidelines is essential for secure Forex trading in India.

What is Forex Market

Forex is a global market where investors can make big financial gains by buying and selling fiat currencies. Although it is a relatively new financial concept in India, the popularity of FX trading among locals has surged. One of the biggest and most liquid markets in the world, it enables investors to amass riches and make significant financial profits.

Is Forex trading allowed in India?

Forex is a global market where investors can make big financial gains by buying and selling fiat currencies. Although it is a relatively new financial concept in India, the popularity of FX trading among locals has surged. One of the biggest and most liquid markets in the world, it enables investors to amass riches and make significant financial profits.

With currency pairs including the US dollar and INR, the euro and INR, and the pound sterling and INR, online or electronic trading is permitted in India. To avoid legal trouble, it is advisable to keep trading through approved trading channels.

Forex Trading Challenges in India

Here are the five biggest forex trading challenges in India:

Legal Restrictions

The legal limitations imposed by the RBI and the SEBI are one of the most important and disruptive issues facing forex traders. Indian citizens are not permitted to trade in foreign exchange markets unless they are doing it for particular, authorized purposes, such as travel, education, or business, according to the RBI. Additionally, the SEBI controls forex brokers operating in India and restricts their ability to offer trading in all but the USD/INR, EUR/INR, GBP/INR, and JPY/INR currency pairs. This means that traders from India are unable to access the foreign exchange market and deal in other common or uncommon currency pairs.

To stop capital flight, money laundering, and currency manipulation, there are legal prohibitions in place. They do, however, also restrict the options and opportunities available to Indian forex traders.

High Fees

The brokers have more control over determining their prices and commissions because there is less competition and regulation in the Indian forex industry. Because of this, Indian traders frequently pay more in fees and spreads than do dealers from other nations. For instance, the average spread for EUR/USD among the top forex brokers worldwide is 0.9 pip, whereas the average spread for USD/INR among the top forex brokers in India is 3.5 pip.

High fees and spreads might reduce Indian traders' profits and make it more difficult for them to generate regular returns.

Market VolatilityThe foreign exchange market is very erratic. But because of the nature of the currency pairs that Indian traders deal with, it can be particularly noticeable. For instance, several variables, including interest rate differences, inflation rates, trade balance, fiscal policy, political stability, geopolitical events, and market mood, have an impact on the USD/INR pair. These variables have the potential to generate abrupt and significant changes in the USD/INR exchange rate, which, for Indian traders, can present both possibilities and risks.

Leverage RiskLeverage risk is a crucial forex trading risk. The forex markets themselves offer the most leverage. Leveraging implies hazards and a 20–30 times ratio, which indicates a high level of risk. A person could lose all of their capital in a matter of minutes if they make highly leveraged bets because there is no cap on the amount of movement that can occur in the forex market on a given day.

Operational RisksOperationally, managing forex trading operations is frequently challenging. The reason is that, in contrast to humans, the market operates continuously. To preserve the value of their investments while they are abroad, the traders might also turn to algorithms. Additionally, international corporations have trading desks located all over the world. As a result, they can only be carried out if trading is done on a massive scale.

It follows that this market could result in substantial losses on the evenings or weekends if a person lacks the funds or is unable to monitor their positions while they are gone.

How can you Trade Forex in India?

Indian citizens can trade on the foreign exchange market through foreign brokers, although they are restricted from using all of the trading tools available. India's participation in the global Forex market is limited by the country's ban on binary trades, in which investors receive a predetermined sum or nothing at all. With no involvement from a third party, binary transactions take place between the trader and the platform. Online trading platforms offer significant leverage to link more traders; some even advertise 100 times the value of the investment. FEMA (Foreign Exchange Management Act) and the RBI's Liberalised Remittance Scheme, however, forbid binary trading.

As there are only four currency pairs available in India—the US dollar, the euro, the pound sterling, and the yen—Indian citizens are only permitted to trade in the FX stock exchange under limited conditions. Due to these limitations, India's forex market is smaller than those of other developed countries. Online marketplaces provide huge leverage as well to link additional traders.

Conclusion

Not just India has restrictions on forex trading. As stated in the FEMA legislation, trading on pairings other than the RBI is prohibited. In India, trading through an online broker is not punishable by bail. Because there are so many online brokers, forex traders are misled. According to RBI, these regulations are in place to stop traders from suffering significant losses. However, a large portion of Indians still think that the major motive is to curb the overabundance of foreign currency in the nation. With Kotak Securities, extensive offerings and professional advice to manage your financial portfolio.

Forex Trading Challenges in India | Kotak Securities (2024)

FAQs

Is forex trading risky in India? ›

On the other hand, if you expect the INR to strengthen against the US Dollar, you can sell US Dollar/Indian Rupee futures. However, it needs to be understood that Forex trading is not for everyone. It comes with a high level of risk.

Why can't i trade forex in India? ›

Forex trading is not illegal, but SEBI and RBI highly regulate it. You can only trade in four currency pairs with the INR as the base or the quote currency. You also need to use a SEBI-registered broker or an authorised dealer to trade legally in forex in India.

Is forex trading profitable in India? ›

Forex trading can be profitable in India, but it requires a combination of skill, knowledge, and discipline. While the forex market offers opportunities for high returns, it also carries significant risks that traders must be aware of and manage effectively.

What is the biggest risk in forex trading? ›

5 common risk factors in Forex Trading
  • Leverage Risk. For leverage in forex trading, a small initial investment known as a margin is necessary for conducting substantial foreign currency trades. ...
  • Transaction Risk. ...
  • Interest Rate Risk. ...
  • Country Risk. ...
  • Counterparty Risk.

Why is forex trading ban in India? ›

In India, however, forex trading platforms are outlawed. While currency trading is not possible on the foreign exchange market, it is possible on the stock exchange. The Foreign Exchange Management Act makes binary trading illegal (FEMA). While dealing in foreign currency is legal, there are several restrictions.

What is the dark side of forex trading? ›

Forex scam risk involves the danger of engaging with fraudulent brokers or falling victim to investment scams promising unrealistic returns. These scams can lead to significant financial losses and erode trust in the Forex trading environment.

How much forex is allowed in India? ›

Forex Card, Traveler's Cheque, and Remittance
RegulationLimit
Cash LimitRs. 25,000
Cash (per trip)USD 3,000
Forex Card/FC Demand Draft/Remittance (per financial year)USD 250,000
Purchase from authorized person (cash limit)Below Rs. 50,000

Who is the number one forex trader in India? ›

Shashikant Sharma became the wealthiest Forex trader in India at 34. His journey began as a 22-year-old and followed the same path most traders can relate to. He browsed the internet and came across an article covering Forex. It intrigued him enough to start his Forex journey.

What is the punishment for forex trading in India? ›

Transactions on recognised exchanges like the BSE, NSE, or MSE are permitted, but trading on unauthorized platforms is prohibited. Violations, such as trading in unapproved currency pairs or using illegal platforms, can result in fines up to Rs 10,000 per day, along with potential imprisonment for up to five years.

Do forex traders pay tax in India? ›

What taxes apply to forex trading? According to section 1256, 60% of your annual earnings are consistently taxed at a fixed rate of 15%. However, the remaining 40% is subject to taxation, which may vary based on your income status.

How to spot a forex scammer? ›

Top three signs you might be dealing with a forex scam
  1. Unbalanced claims. ...
  2. Requests for money. ...
  3. Lifestyle pictures or testimonials from “successful” traders. ...
  4. Unregulated (or lightly regulated) forex brokers. ...
  5. Binary options. ...
  6. Clone firms. ...
  7. Social media scams and imposters. ...
  8. Scam signal providers.
Mar 5, 2024

Which forex is legal in India? ›

Yes, forex trading is legal in India but with certain restrictions. As stated earlier, forex trading can only be done through a registered Indian broker. Additionally, forex trading is limited to specific currency pairs such as USD/INR, EUR/INR, JPY/INR, and GBP/INR.

Why 90% of forex traders lose money? ›

The reason many forex traders fail is that they are undercapitalized in relation to the size of the trades they make. It is either greed or the prospect of controlling vast amounts of money with only a small amount of capital that coerces forex traders to take on such huge and fragile financial risk.

Is forex trading safe in India? ›

Yes, Forex trading is legal in India, but it is regulated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) and the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI).

Why do 95 of forex traders fail? ›

Many people fail in Forex trading because they don't have enough education and preparation. Now, Emotions Play a Big Role Here - Getting too worked up when things don't go as planned is a common mistake.

Is forex com safe in India? ›

Yes, forex trading is legal in India, but it is subject to certain restrictions set by the Foreign Exchange Management Act (FEMA) and regulated by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI). Forex transactions can only be undertaken with authorized persons and for permitted purposes.

Is forex considered high risk? ›

Businesses that deal in Forex are generally regarded as high-risk because of the volatile nature of international currency markets.

Is there any punishment for forex trading in India? ›

Transactions on recognised exchanges like the BSE, NSE, or MSE are permitted, but trading on unauthorized platforms is prohibited. Violations, such as trading in unapproved currency pairs or using illegal platforms, can result in fines up to Rs 10,000 per day, along with potential imprisonment for up to five years.

Is it risky to invest in forex? ›

Statistics show that most aspiring forex traders fail, and some even lose large amounts of money. Leverage is a double-edged sword, as it can lead to outsized profits but also substantial losses. Counterparty risks, platform malfunctions, and sudden bursts of volatility also pose challenges to would-be forex traders.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Kerri Lueilwitz

Last Updated:

Views: 6303

Rating: 4.7 / 5 (67 voted)

Reviews: 90% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Kerri Lueilwitz

Birthday: 1992-10-31

Address: Suite 878 3699 Chantelle Roads, Colebury, NC 68599

Phone: +6111989609516

Job: Chief Farming Manager

Hobby: Mycology, Stone skipping, Dowsing, Whittling, Taxidermy, Sand art, Roller skating

Introduction: My name is Kerri Lueilwitz, I am a courageous, gentle, quaint, thankful, outstanding, brave, vast person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.