Foreign vs. American Cars (2024)

How are foreign cars and American cars different?

A few decades ago, America's automotive reputation wasn't that great. The public saw American cars as poorly manufactured and unreliable compared to Japanese and German exports. But times have changed, and American car manufacturers have stepped up their game to compete with international competitors. The differences between domestic vs. foreign cars aren't quite as stark anymore. There are pros and cons to each, but in the end, it mainly comes down to personal preference and what you want in a car.

What is an American car?

Technically, there's no such thing as a 100% American-made car anymore. Some technology or materials used to build American vehicles will come from overseas. But generally, American car companies headquartered in the U.S. use domestically made engines and transmissions, and manufacture their cars in American factories. Some of the top American car companies include Ford, Chrysler, and General Motors. Common features of cars made by American companies include larger size, affordable luxury, support for American workers and ease in having parts replaced.

Many American car brands focus on larger vehicles like SUVs and pickup trucks. American drivers often favor larger vehicles, while compact cars tend to be more popular overseas. You can find SUVs and trucks from foreign brands, but American carmakers tend to have a better selection. Brands like Porsche, Mercedes, and BMW may come to mind when you imagine a luxury car. But many American car companies incorporate luxury elements into their designs and often with a lower price tag than imports.

You can still support American workers by shopping for foreign brands. Many have U.S. manufacturing plants that employ local workers. A good way to maximize support and dollars going toward American workers is to buy from companies headquartered in the United States. If you purchase an imported vehicle, chances are that replacement parts will need to be imported too. This can be pricey and take a long time, depending on how specialized the part is. If a U.S. company built your car, it is often easier and more affordable for a mechanic to obtain the part you need.

What are the benefits of foreign cars vs. American cars?

Cars manufactured in Asia or Europe often have the following characteristics when compared to American cars:

  • Reliability. Even though the reputation of American cars has improved over the years, foreign car manufacturers are almost always top-rated when it comes to performance and reliability. The car buying public recognizes Japanese car brands Toyota, Mazda, and Lexus as the most reliable options on the market. A reliable car will likely require fewer repairs and last longer.
  • Fuel efficiency. Overall, foreign-made cars have better fuel efficiency when compared to American models. As a result, you won't need to fill the tank as often, and you'll end up spending less money on gas. A car with excellent fuel efficiency is also better for the environment.
  • Lower price. The most affordable car lists often include some models from American brands. Still, foreign brands like Hyundai and Kia sell some of the most affordable cars in the United States.

Does an imported car affect insurance?

Car insurance rates are calculated based on the make and model of a car, and there isn't specific import car insurance. Whether a car is foreign or domestic is rarely a factor. Insurance companies are more interested in looking at the size and power of a vehicle rather than the company that made it. It would likely cost more to insure an American-made sports car compared with a sedan made by a European or Asian car company. The best insurance for imported cars is often the same you'd choose for an American car. Compare different plans to find the one that's right for you.

Are imported cars more expensive to insure?

You may find imported car insurance is more expensive when it comes to comprehensive car insurance coverage or auto collision coverage because replacement parts can cost more. This can lead insurance companies to increase premium rates to cover that extra cost. But this mainly applies to specialized cars.

Major companies like Toyota and Mercedes have manufacturing plants in the U.S., so getting parts for popular models shouldn't be difficult. But parts for specialty cars – imported or domestic – can be expensive and difficult to get. This can lead to higher car insurance premiums. If you own specialty cars that you don't drive regularly, you may also consider temporary car insurance for imported cars to cover the period of time when you'll be driving.

Get the right coverage for your car with Progressive

Current Progressive customers

You can log in or call 1-866-749-7436 to adjust your coverages.

New Progressive customers

Quote auto insurance online or call 1-866-749-7436 to insure your car.

Foreign vs. American Cars (2024)

FAQs

Which is better, foreign or American cars? ›

Even though the reputation of American cars has improved over the years, foreign car manufacturers are almost always top-rated when it comes to performance and reliability. The car buying public recognizes Japanese car brands Toyota, Mazda, and Lexus as the most reliable options on the market.

Is it better to buy a foreign car? ›

Are American cars reliable? According to Consumer Reports, all of the top 10 most reliable vehicles of 2023 come from foreign automakers, with Lexus, Toyota, Mini, Acura and Honda topping the list. Among American manufacturers, only Buick, Tesla and Ram rank in the top 15 for reliability.

Which cars are better American or European? ›

American cars prioritize practicality over aesthetics, often resulting in larger and less fuel-efficient vehicles. European cars are smaller, fuel-efficient, stylish, and high-performing. Knowing this can help you choose the right car for your needs when buying or renting in Europe.

Do foreign cars last longer? ›

Yes, Japanese Cars Last Longer!

An extensive study conducted by the Curtis Laws Wilson Library demonstrates that Japanese cars are generally more long-lived than their American and European counterparts. The average life expectancy of an automobile is about 8 years, or about 150,000 miles.

Are Japanese or American cars better? ›

When considering factors such as performance, safety features and price, Japanese cars consistently outperform American models in affordability, fuel-economy and reliability rankings, however, U.S. brands are well-known for producing robust trucks and SUVs.

Are German cars better than us? ›

Mechanically, German cars are better than most, according to critics. Reliability issues aside, German cars are ideal for those craving speed and comfort, and the peace of mind that they only have to change vehicles on average every 200,000-250,000 miles (with proper maintenance).

Why do people want foreign cars? ›

Foreign cars tend to last much longer and run better than domestic cars. The average domestic vehicle will start to experience problems around 100,000 miles, while foreign vehicles will last longer than 100,000 miles with proper maintenance.

Do foreign cars cost more to repair? ›

Foreign cars tend to be more specialized than domestic vehicles so mechanics specialized in foreign car repairs may charge higher rates. However, it's important to remember that parts and labor costs for domestic cars can be just as expensive as those associated with foreign vehicles.

How long do American cars last? ›

While that case may be an extreme outlier, most modern cars are expected to last 200,000 miles before experiencing some significant failure. That's roughly double the lifespan of cars from the 1960s and 1970s, which typically lasted about 100,000 miles.

Which country has the best quality of cars? ›

12 Countries That Produce the Best Cars in the World
  • Czech Republic. Car Exports as of 2021: $23 billion. ...
  • People's Republic of China. Car Exports as of 2021: $24 billion. ...
  • Slovak Republic. Car Exports as of 2021: $26 billion. ...
  • Canada. ...
  • United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland. ...
  • Kingdom of Belgium. ...
  • Kingdom of Spain.
Dec 16, 2022

Why are American cars not sold in Europe? ›

Traditionally, they were grossly fuel hungry, underbraked and the suspension poorly set-up for many European roads. They did not enjoy a price advantage either because they are all imported. Some that Americans will recognise ARE seen however.

What are the cons of European cars? ›

Keep in mind that it's not just a journey through problems, but also a roadmap to solutions!
  • Electrical Complexities. ...
  • Engine Cooling System Failures. ...
  • Transmission Issues. ...
  • Oil Leaks and Consumption. ...
  • Suspension and Steering Concerns. ...
  • Specific Ways To Avoid Problems in European Vehicles. ...
  • Tires Are Essential.
Jan 27, 2024

Are foreign cars more expensive to insure? ›

American cars may have lower repair costs, while foreign cars have a reputation for fuel efficiency. But there's not much difference in the cost of insuring foreign versus domestic cars.

Why are American cars better? ›

The chassis components stand up better than overseas products on bad roads. The bodies do not rattle or corrode. A well-used American car with 100,000 miles on the odometer will still bring a fantastic price — in other lands.

Which car lasts the longest in the world? ›

Longest-lasting cars
  • Toyota Avalon, 33.1%
  • Honda Accord, 27.1%
  • Toyota Camry, 20.4%
  • Toyota Matrix, 16.7%
  • Subaru Legacy, 16.2%
  • Lexus GS 300, 15.9%
  • Acura RL, 14.9%
  • Honda Civic, 14.7%
Jun 15, 2023

Are foreign cars expensive to fix? ›

Unless you buy a small compact, foreign car, it typically costs more than domestic vehicles and is one of the most expensive models to upkeep.

What is the best foreign car company? ›

1) Porsche | Winner

It is best known for its luxury sports cars, including the highly ranked 2022 Cayman, 2022 Boxster and 2022 911. These cars owe their success to precision handling, heart-racing acceleration and excellent build quality. They are also highly customizable.

What is the most reliable car brand in the US? ›

According to car owners' feedback in the U.S. nonprofit Consumer Reports' annual survey, Lexus—the luxury arm of Toyota—is the most reliable car brand in the country. Japanese manufacturers have impressed again this year—no surprises there.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Manual Maggio

Last Updated:

Views: 6334

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 80% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Manual Maggio

Birthday: 1998-01-20

Address: 359 Kelvin Stream, Lake Eldonview, MT 33517-1242

Phone: +577037762465

Job: Product Hospitality Supervisor

Hobby: Gardening, Web surfing, Video gaming, Amateur radio, Flag Football, Reading, Table tennis

Introduction: My name is Manual Maggio, I am a thankful, tender, adventurous, delightful, fantastic, proud, graceful person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.